Opinion Links: Opinion Home Page | Latest Expert Columns | Latest Blog Entries
Posted: 30th June 2008 16:37
Monty: Talented but temperamental?
More than anything, I hope he shows some respect and compassion for those who have helped him achieve the heights he has reached in a glorious golfing career - a career that by the looks of last Sunday, has some golden moments still to come.
Ewen Murray on Colin Montgomerie.
Quotes of the week
I said last week that Colin Montgomerie has been written off before and has then come back and surprised many.
In France, Montgomerie found top gear again, and with his second place finish at Le Golf National, he has forced his way back into the Ryder reckoning.
Monty never fails to amaze. His golf last week was sublime, the Colin of old.
When he is on form, he is hugely impressive. He has the look of someone who holds the club with the lightest of grip pressure and his swing is poetry in motion. When the heat is at its highest level, his nerve is at its calmest and his putting is assured.
If Colin had an on-course temperament to match his off-course demeanour, he would have won six Majors by now.
When Nick Faldo felt the heat down the closing stretch, he saw and heard nothing, such was his focus on what he was trying to achieve.
Colin spends too much time looking for something to complain about and sadly for him, he usually finds it.
Over the years, I have watched with admiration the talent of Montgomerie.
The arrow-like precision off the tee, iron shots hit and, as if guided by radar, landing by the pin, and pressure putts falling at the correct speed to find the bottom of the hole.
He has upped the quality of European Tour golf, continually improving as the years pass by. Others have had to do the same to hang on to his coat-tails.
His excellence has done much for the next generation because he has set such exacting targets and over his twenty years as a professional, his superb natural ability has graced many of our fine tournaments.
I would like to leave it there because as a lover of great golf, Colin has given me hours of enjoyment. Sadly, I cannot condone his behaviour.
For someone who is wonderful company away from the sport, I cannot explain why his manners are so poor on the course.
In France on Sunday, a young lad got it in the ear for daring to breathe twenty yards from the burly Scot. He retreated to his dad's side close to tears.
Last week we were guests of the French people at one of our Tour's oldest events. Marshalls continually receive a blast, yet they give their time for the love of their sport and do a fine job.
Spectators who pay good money to watch their hobby played well, are often in the Monty firing line.
Having joined the European Tour at the start in 1971, I can think of no other player who has behaved in the same fashion down the years.
Colin may say it's the competitiveness in him and it's part of his will to win.
Well, Jack, Arnie, Lee and Tom were competitive, but they had a respect for all who were part of the game and for the tournaments they played in across the world.
Tiger Woods would never blame anyone but himself for poor shots - excuses are not in his repertoire.
I know we are all different and thank goodness we are or it would be a dull world, but I think Colin's manners, or lack of them, have stopped him being mentioned in the same breath as those above.
I hope he wins a major, makes the Ryder Cup for the ninth time, wins the order of merit for the ninth time and so on, because his game deserves it.
But more than anything, I hope he shows some respect and compassion for those who have helped and supported him, enabling him to achieve the heights he has reached in what has been a glorious golfing career - a career that by the looks of last Sunday, has some golden moments still to come.
The winner in Versailles was a revelation.
Pablo Larrazabal lit up the event with some scintillating golf reminiscent of Seve in the Seventies.
Now it is much too early to say he can go on to achieve what Ballesteros managed, but he played with that same devil-may-care attitude and a smile was never far from his face.
His golfing life has changed, as has his bank balance, but he deserves it.
Having come through the pre qualifying at Chantilly, his tournament was a six-rounder and the fact he saw off Lee Westwood, Soren Hansen and Colin Montgomerie made this victory sweeter.
The manner in which he won impressed everyone.
Having secured a handsome lead coming into the fearsome last four holes, Pablo ignored the pins and headed for the safe side of the greens. Fifteen feet left at the 15th, 30 feet left at 16 and, understandably, 70 feet left at the last.
Even then, he played them in two under par. You would expect that from a seasoned campaigner, but not from a rookie.
He won beautifully, and we will look forward to his progress in the months ahead. All sorts of doors have opened up for the Spaniard. He now has to make every effort to walk on through them.
This week, the London Club is the new venue for the European Open.
Designed by Jack Nicklaus, it is a modern lay out that meanders around the Kent countryside. Its tough, long and only precise iron play will be rewarded.
The afore mentioned Colin Montgomerie defends the title he won superbly at the K Club last year and it is another opportunity for Colin to force his way into Nick Faldo's side for Valhalla in September.
As you would expect, one of the strongest fields of the season will compete for another huge purse.
Last week, I was joined in the "box" by Ian Poulter who currently is struggling to find his best form. My opinion is that form is not far away.
The quicker greens of the London Club will suit him and it's only his putting that is holding him back.
His last round 68 in France was just the tonic he needs, and I expect a sound performance from the Englishman. Ian is now home for a lengthy spell and I think that is what he needed.
As I said last week, he looked low in confidence at the US Open. A good showing in Kent will restore his belief and a confident Poulter is always a contender.
Thanks again for your input over the last week and I'm sure you will have your own thoughts on this week's topics.
Enjoy the European Open on Sky Sports - we have over 20 hours of live coverage starting on Thursday.
A seven-under-par 63 from Rory Sabbatini allowed him to move to the top of the leaderboard after the third round of the Texas Open.
South African Charl Schwartzel birdied the 18th to move into a one-shot lead at the end of the third round of the Madrid Masters.
A six-under-par round of 64 allowed Chris Stroud to move to the top of the leaderboard after round two of the Texas Open.
Doctors treating Seve Ballesteros say tests have revealed he is suffering from a "grave illness".
Collated third round scores from the European Tour event in Madrid.
Comments
Mark Frary says...
What a shame we have to endure the aggressive behavior of a very talented golfer who will be remembered in time not for his golf but for his antics on the course ! he is not in the same league as mr faldo and ballesteros both on the course and off it .
Posted 13:28 9th July 2008
Linda M says...
I don't by any means condone Monty's on course surly attitude but can understand it to some extent. The trouble is, what was once an isolated and perhaps justified incident is now becoming a very bad habit and I have read of many occasions now when he has been particularly hurtful to young fans. That kind of attitude is just not acceptable no matter who it is. I too, was at the London Club and watched him tee off. My companion's comment was "I'm not following that miserable g*** !!!" The press photographers all trouped off after him, waiting to capture the moment of the next provoked, or more probably these days, unprovoked outburst. To some extent his comments to the tv crew were right. They were only there because of his status. They wouldn't be following a 'nobody' would they? Lets remember, Monty is not alone in this attitude but he is the prime culprit of the worst example. I've seen many a Tour pro totally blank a fan on practise rounds when they do have the opportunity to acknowledge the paying public. A little humilty wouldn't go amiss. Yes, his talent has given him a very priviliged life but it's our hard earned cash and the sponsors money that maintains it so it's about time Monty acknowledged that and said "Sorry" to the fans and the PGA. Ewen, have a word with him, please. He is building a reputation for all the worst reasons and his shot making skills and playing record deserves better than that!
Posted 17:51 7th July 2008
Chris Kirby says...
Dear Ewan, I have been a long time admirer of Colin Montgomerie as a player and ambassador of the European tour. His record is outstanding save only the unbelievable missing majors. I attended the opening day at the London Club last week and watched Colin as I do when I go to golf tournaments. I have to say that the incident with the cameraman was the last straw. I thought his comments were outrageous. "You are here because of me" Monty was on the prowl the day I watched him and I notice he is always looking around making eye contact and surveying what is going on around him. All of the other players I watched were focused on their objective. I agree perhaps if he wasn't waiting for someone to breathe out of turn he would have a stack of majors. He really has a problem and can only blame himself. Chris Kirby
Posted 13:16 7th July 2008
William Walker says...
Well said Ewen.......Yes, Monty, fantastic and compulsive viewing in full flow...... though fractious at times. Leave the kids alone Colin they are the future supporters of tournament golf
Posted 12:33 6th July 2008
Allan Pratt says...
I am currently watching the European Open and am disgusted by the behaviour of Montgomerie. What an Arrogant, Ignorant, bad mannered, spoilt child he is. (Did I forget 'Priveleged'). To tell a cameraman he is only there because of C. Montgomerie. Please stop giving him so much coverage and treat him with the disdain that he deserves. I congratulate the commentators and His playing partner - Ian Poulter for showing him up for what he is, a disgraceful ambassador for Britain. Please, please, please, not in our Ryder Cup.
Posted 00:25 6th July 2008
Clive Attenborough says...
Hi Ewen, I went to the Wales open 2 years ago to watch colin montgomerie. After he birdied a hole I said "well played colin..keep it going" He just glared at me as if I had sworn, then his caddie barged me out of the way. He doesn't deserve the following he has. I brought my children up to respect everyone. He's a disgrace to the spirit of the game.
Posted 22:48 5th July 2008
John Mccann says...
Regarding Monty's outburst on the 13th yesterday, here is a quotation from the Etiquette section of the Rules of Golf "All players should conduct themselves in a disciplined manner, demonstrating courtesy and sportsmanship at all times, irrespective of how competitive they maybe. This is the spirit of the game of golf" . With every infringement of this Etiquette Monty looses some of the respect of the golfing public . ----- Original Me
Posted 15:38 5th July 2008
Chris Mccallum says...
Poor old Monty. Always on the end of some snide remarks from the commentators. One, which I thought was particularly awful was, 'that's better, Monty's back on solids again!' Admittedly he does get himself a bit uptight now and again, but as I'm not the one out there and have no idea how much the tension is getting to him, hey! ho! His swing is a joy to watch and when he's on his game.....magic!
Posted 14:36 5th July 2008
Paul Dubrow says...
I wanted to say that I thought Colin Montgonerie's behaviour on Friday was disgraceful. I followed the match most of the way round in person. He was generally "grumpy" with everyone around, more particularly so, when he hit a bad shot. Particularly from the 13 tee, when he hit his 3 wood into the water. He stood on the tees for some time, glaring in every direction as if it was our fault ! meanwhile Sterne had tee's up his ball, but had to wait until the tantrum was over. There was also an exchange of words with a Sky cameraman on the 14th hole. Even a lowly club member would be ticked off, and rightly so, for such poor etiquette, but someone of Colin's experience should be severly repremanded. He is a profession golfer, and should set an even better example. I have copied this to the European Tour also. Despite is many fine playing qualities, he acts like a spoilt child, and there is no excuse for it. He should be sanctioned severely for his poor behaviour
Posted 14:20 5th July 2008
Dee Mccourt says...
"You're only here because of me!" This comment, from Montgomery to a TV cameraman, surely says it all!! I certainly do NOT watch golf on TV just because Montgomery is playing - there are lots of other excellent golfers who contribute to my watching pleasure. The man is rude, arrogant and surly and I think someone should give him a good dose of humility. If he never appeared on TV again I, for one, wouldn't miss his sour face.
Posted 17:35 4th July 2008
Thomas Bullioch says...
i cant believe some of the comments im reading sure at times montys behaviour is not accaptable but these are isolated incidents. i have followed monty several times round a golf course and one of the best things i have seen was at the 14th hole at loch lomand last year he had just holed out and while walking to the next tee he lay his ball beside a young girl who was lying sleeping and look on the girls eyes as she woke was priceless. i do wish he was like this all the time so we could all focus on his great golf and also the charity work we dose which again is mostly for young kids(hsbc wee wonders,chas)
Posted 15:24 2nd July 2008
Yen chong Yap says...
Monty is just another bad case of a 'Bad workman blaming his tools'. For his own good I think he should lay off competitive golf for a while to release off the bad 'chi'. I would like him to be remembered as the 'most improved' player instead of golf fans 'most despised' player when he is no longer playing in the Tour
Posted 14:28 2nd July 2008
Stephen Morrison says...
For years now we have watched Monty, easily my favourite player as a kid, conduct himself on a golf course like this. It is after all such a trying life for a successful golfer, especially one with his quality, career, record and money. Monty was brought up with a far more priveliged life than some and had more chances with his life than perhaps 99% of the rest of the population of Britain. Sure he has worked hard and deserves all he has, but it is time that he showed a bit of more class and touch of humility. Perhaps he should take a closer look at some of the people in life whom have very little chance of succeeding in any shape or form because the odds are stacked against them from birth; and be thankful for the life that he has.
Posted 14:21 2nd July 2008
Glenn Saunders says...
Like many before me have said, his behaviour and attitude towards the people who effiectively pay his wages, stinks !!! The guy plays a sport he loves everyday of his life and gets paid extremely well for doing so, you'd think he would show a little gratitude to all those people who have given their hard earned money to watch him over the years, they are the ones who made him rich after all !!!
Posted 13:14 2nd July 2008
John Halliday says...
at times when i turn on sky sports and see monty i cant believe my eyes. as ewan points out for a golfer who is so talanted to let such simple aspects of the game distract him one can only image what he might have won if he could have kept his focus. as a youngster a make no secret that monty was my golfing hero many a late night was spent at my course pretending to be monty putting from 8feet for the open maybe a at birkdale in a few weeks the putt will finally drop........
Posted 10:26 2nd July 2008
Damien Morris says...
hi ewen just 2 say i was very impressed with the way pablo larrazabal contrtolled his emotions on the final day of the french open. His holing out was exemplary all week as statistics show with him only taking 91 putts for the four days of the tournament. It is incredible that he had 30 putts less than montgomerie to hole out throughout the week. He is a definite major winner for the future.i am disappointed with Darren Clarke and Paul Mcginley failing to qualify for the Open Championship at Royal Birkdale as it is a glorious opportunity to perform well at the open to get the necessary points to haul themselves back into the Ryder Cup race. i hope they can challenge in the London club in Kent this week.
Posted 22:40 1st July 2008
Tim B says...
I do not care how many order of merit's etc Monty has won, if he shouted at my son at a golf tournament then i would give him a piece of my mind. How many more times is he going to be allowed to get away with this?, fair enough if the child had shouted, used his phone etc but to be humiltiated and no doubt scared for something so minor is beyond a joke. I lost all respect for Monty a long time ago and after his comments when interviewed after the 3rd round last week where he belittled Larazabal and implied that he would not be able to take the pressure in the last round i was hoping and praying that he would win and was delighted that he did so.
Posted 16:51 1st July 2008
Scott Beaumont says...
oh monty ! ! take a break..... have a kit-kat ! what a shame he behaves like that now and again. Remember 06 US Open where he was allleged to have knocked a state guard over and thrown a tee-peg at someone ? Ewen, what went wrong for Darren Clarke at Sunningdale ? interesting quote from him after morning round "looks like im fishing in 3weeks!" hmmm I wonder if Tiger would feel the same with another 18holes left to play ? lack of self belief perhaps ?
Posted 14:49 1st July 2008
John Lison says...
l think montys behavour on the golf course is terrible he should be told if he cannot behave he cannot play on tour ,he his setting a bad example to the young players coming through, also he should remember if there were no crowds the prize money would be a lot less, as he gets older his behavour gets worse it is time the pga did something we want to see quality golf not schoolboy tantrums
Posted 10:57 1st July 2008
Ian Ford says...
I too have had the pleasure of spending time in Mr. Montgomerie's company away from the golf course, he is indeed great company to be with. I cannot believe the way he behaves on the course, he's played in some real high pressure matches in the Ryder Cup where not a thing has bothered him, yet to almost reduce a child to tears is a real pity. Monty should know better, he seems to be looking for others to blame rather than laying the blame at his own feet when he underperforms. Glad he has found some form at last, just wish his off course charm could follow him onto the tees, fairways & greens...
Posted 10:25 1st July 2008
Add Comment*
All fields are required